
Between Restaurant Responsibility, Regulatory Shortcomings, and the Consumer’s Right to Protection
Food Safety in Lebanon: When the Camera Precedes the Law
By Lawyer Michel Fallah
Media campaigns and television investigations into food safety in some Lebanese restaurants are no longer just news about potential health violations. They have brought back to the forefront a more serious legal question: Does a citizen need a television camera to feel safe about his food? Is it conceivable that supervisory bodies move only after suspicion spreads, when their mission is supposed to be to detect danger before it reaches the table?
The food poisoning incidents raised in the autumn of 2026 brought this question back to the top of public attention, and pushed the government to take additional supervisory measures. But consumer protection is not achieved by closing an establishment or punishing a violator alone, but by a legal system that guarantees prevention and accountability, while at the same time preserving the rights of establishments whose violation has not been proven.
The Law Exists… Where Is Its Effectiveness?
Food Safety Law No. 35 of 24 November 2015 was issued to set a legislative framework for regulating food safety at all stages of its production, import, storage, transport and circulation. It created the Lebanese Food Safety Authority, and granted it competencies in risk assessment, control, coordination and alert. Significantly, Article 21 did not merely allow precautionary measures, but obligated the concerned administrations to inform the public about potential risks and ways to prevent them, in application of the principle of transparency.
However, appointing the Authority’s Board of Directors was not enough to complete its activation. In November 2026, the implementing decrees were still being completed, with continued shortage in human resources and equipment. Here lies the paradox: more than a decade after the law was issued, its implementation tools still need completion, while food risks do not wait for the administration to be completed.
The Restaurant’s Responsibility Does Not Begin When Poisoning Occurs
An administrative license does not grant a restaurant permanent health immunity, but imposes on it a continuous obligation to respect food safety conditions. These conditions include the safety of raw materials, their sources, cleanliness of preparation areas, water safety, cooling and storage temperatures, worker health, and prevention of cross-contamination.
But determining responsibility requires distinguishing between the restaurant that served the food, the supplier who sold it, and the party that transported or stored it. Contamination may occur before the food material reaches the restaurant, and may occur during preparation or storage. Therefore, traceability is not a formal procedure, but a legal and scientific means to determine the source of danger, and to distribute responsibilities on the basis of proven facts.
When Does the State Bear Responsibility for Food Harm?
The State’s function is not limited to pursuing violating establishments, but includes exercising preventive control within the competencies defined by law. However, the occurrence of a poisoning case does not automatically make the State responsible for its consequences. Administrative liability for a service fault requires, in principle, proving a specific supervisory duty, a breach of that duty by the administration, the occurrence of damage, and a causal link between the breach and the damage.
The question of the administration’s responsibility may arise if it is proven that it received serious information about a specific food danger, then abstained without justification from taking the measures imposed by law. But if the administration exercised its powers in accordance with procedures, the occurrence of damage alone is not sufficient to prove its negligence. The State is not an absolute guarantor of the safety of every meal, but it is responsible for respecting the supervisory duties entrusted to it by law.
Precautionary Closure Is Not a Judicial Conviction
Health legislation allows urgent measures to be taken when a serious danger threatening public health appears, in accordance with the competencies and procedures specified by law. These measures may include withdrawing products, stopping their circulation, or temporarily closing the establishment. But a precautionary measure differs from a criminal penalty.
The first aims to prevent the continuation of danger, while a criminal conviction requires proving the elements of the crime and respecting the rights of defense and the presumption of innocence. The administrative decision must also remain proportionate to the danger, and be subject to review in accordance with procedures. Temporary closure must not turn into a permanent punishment without a legal basis, just as necessary health protection must not be delayed under the pretext of awaiting a criminal judgment.
Has the Camera Become an Alternative Supervisory Authority?
The media has a legitimate role in uncovering health risks, alerting citizens, and holding establishments and public authorities accountable. But a television investigation does not replace official seizure reports, laboratory tests, or judicial investigation. Proving a health violation does not necessarily mean proving a criminal offense, just as suspicion does not justify issuing prejudgments against an establishment whose reputation may suffer serious damage.
On the other hand, protection of commercial reputation must not be used to prevent the publication of reliable information about a danger threatening consumers. The required balance is based on verifying facts, distinguishing between suspicion and proven violation, allowing the right of reply, and giving priority to warning about serious risks. The media has the right to uncover, the administration has the duty to supervise, and the judiciary has the authority to decide responsibilities.
What Do Foreign Laws Say?
The European experience provides a model based on prevention and determining responsibilities. Article 17 of European Regulation No. 178/2002 holds food business operators responsible for respecting legislation in the stages under their control, while Articles 18 and 19 regulate product traceability, withdrawal of unsafe food, and informing authorities. Regulation No. 852/2004 imposes health procedures based on Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points principles.
France, for its part, adopted the “Alim’confiance” system for publishing results of official health controls, according to four levels ranging from a very satisfactory health situation to cases requiring urgent correction. The owner of the establishment is granted a fifteen-day period to present his observations before publishing the result, while results remain available to the public for one year.
In Egypt, Law No. 1 of 2017 created the National Food Safety Authority, with the aim of strengthening control and unifying the competent reference.
The comparison reveals that transparency and institutional prevention are more effective than limiting action to penalties after damage occurs.
Towards a National Health Classification for Restaurants
The required reform in Lebanon does not necessarily begin with a new law, but with completing the activation of the existing law. This requires providing human and technical resources for the Lebanese Food Safety Authority, clarifying the distribution of competencies, and adopting periodic inspection based on risk assessment. But the most important step is creating a declared national system for classifying the health safety of restaurants and food establishments.
This system should include publishing the inspection date, its result, the nature of violations, and measures taken, according to unified standards, while guaranteeing the establishment’s right to present its observations, object, correct violations, and update its classification after re-inspection. This requires a clear regulatory basis defining the authority to publish, its controls and effects, without confusing the duty to warn of danger with publishing a comprehensive periodic classification. Transparency does not mean defamation, but enabling the consumer to choose on the basis of reliable official information.
From a Culture of Scandal to a State of Prevention
Food safety is not the responsibility of restaurants alone, nor a media issue that ends with the end of a television investigation. It is a legal obligation distributed between producer, supplier, restaurant and supervisory authorities, and subject to accountability according to each party’s responsibility. What is required is not a state that moves when a violation is exposed, but a state that makes detecting the violation and preventing its effects a permanent function of its institutions.
When a citizen can view control results before entering a restaurant, and an establishment can prove its compliance with health standards, the law becomes a source of trust instead of remaining a tool for accountability after damage occurs. True food security does not begin with the camera that reveals danger, but with the law that prevents it from reaching the citizen’s table.
Sources and References
- Lebanon – Food Safety Law No. 35 of 24 November 2015, particularly Article 21 on precautionary measures and informing the public of risks, and provisions on the Authority and control.
- Lebanese Ministry of Public Health, legal texts adopted for monitoring food establishments, and related health specifications.
- Lebanese Presidency of the Council of Ministers, 1 November 2026, announcement of an emergency meeting to follow up on food poisoning cases, suspected fraud, and strengthening control.
- Al-Nahar, 4 November 2026, investigation on human resources of the Lebanese Food Safety Authority and implementing decrees awaiting completion of procedures.
- European Union – Regulation No. 178/2002, Articles 17, 18 and 19, on responsibilities of food establishments, traceability and withdrawal of unsafe products.
- European Union – Regulation No. 852/2004, on food hygiene and hazard analysis procedures.
- France – Decree of 15 December 2016 No. 2016-1750 and implementing decision of 28 February 2017, on publishing results of official health controls.
- French Ministry of Agriculture – Alim’confiance, system for classifying food establishments and publishing results and guaranteeing submission of observations before publication.
- Egypt – Law No. 1 of 2017, on establishing the National Food Safety Authority and its supervisory competencies.






