Immunity and the Law: Are Lebanese Really Equal Before Justice?

⚖️ ANALYSIS | Woujouhwahdass News
By Lawyer Michel Fallah

Immunity and the Law: Are Lebanese Really Equal Before Justice?

In Lebanon, a citizen and an official do not always stand before the judiciary through the same door. While the first is subject, in principle, to the general rules of prosecution, the second may be surrounded by constitutional immunities, administrative authorizations and exceptional procedures that make accountability far more complex.

The problem is not the existence of these guarantees, but the question that arises every time an investigation stalls: Was immunity created to protect public office from arbitrariness, or has its interpretation come to protect some office-holders from accountability?

Equality before the law, enshrined in Article 7 of the Lebanese Constitution, does not mean identical procedures for all, but it rejects turning procedural differences into personal privileges that obstruct justice.

Parliamentary Immunity: Protecting the Office or the Holder?
Article 39 protects an MP from criminal prosecution for opinions expressed during his mandate, while Article 40 requires Parliament’s permission for criminal proceedings during session, except in flagrante delicto. The first is a substantive protection of parliamentary free speech, the second a procedural guarantee that does not erase the crime.

For ministers, Articles 70 and 71 allow Parliament to accuse the Prime Minister and ministers of high treason or breach of their duties, by a two-thirds majority, and try them before the Supreme Council. The key question: Does “breach of duties” cover any crime committed while in office, or only acts intrinsically linked to ministerial function?

Beirut Port Explosion: When Jurisdiction Becomes Part of the Case
The port blast investigation is the clearest test. It has involved former PM Hassan Diab, former ministers Ali Hassan Khalil, Ghazi Zeaiter and Youssef Fenianos, alongside security and administrative officials. The debate went beyond facts to the jurisdiction of Judicial Investigator Tarek Bitar.

Recently, on the 4th of this month, Bitar questioned four retired senior officers, including former Chief of Staff Maj. Gen. Walid Salman, as he prepares his indictment.

More than six years without a final trial raises a legitimate question about judicial effectiveness, but it does not justify presuming guilt.

Security Officials and Riad Salameh
For some officials and military personnel, prosecution may require administrative authorization. How can judicial independence be guaranteed if prosecution depends on approval from the executive?

The cases of former Central Bank Governor Riad Salameh present a different model: not ministerial immunity, but financial responsibility. On the 5th of this month, the “Forry” and “V Invest” files saw developments, including an in-person arrest warrant.

What Does Comparative Law Say?
In France, Article 68-1 provides for criminal responsibility of government members before the Court of Justice of the Republic. In Italy, Article 96 subjects the PM and ministers to ordinary courts, with parliamentary authorization.

What Reform Would Restore Balance?
Lebanon does not need to abolish immunities, but to reset their limits: clarify the jurisdiction of the Supreme Council, review prosecution authorizations, ensure decisions within reasonable deadlines, and strengthen judicial independence.

Equality begins at the courthouse door. Justice is not stripping everyone of immunity, but keeping immunity within the purpose for which it was enacted.

The final question for the Lebanese legislator: Do we want an immunity that protects the State from arbitrariness, or an immunity that protects power-holders from the State?